Link
Try one for yourself to help you identify the meta-narratives in Scott Pilgrim
Showing posts with label Metanarratives. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Metanarratives. Show all posts
Tuesday, 20 March 2012
Wednesday, 7 March 2012
Derridas Manifesto
Dubbed The Postmodern Manifesto, found among the papers of Jacques Derrida on his death in 2004 and, as yet, unpublished.
Derrida (1930-2004), a philosopher, was one of the three wise French-men who, as it were, spawned Postmodernism, defined, embellished and obscured it; his peers in the matter were the long dominant literary critic Roland Barthes (1915-1980) and Michel Foucault (1926-1984), another philosopher.
From this it must be evident that Postmodernism was a French intellectual movement with a literary-cum-philosophical origin rather than one engendered by artists and the visual arts - indeed, painting, sculpture and architecture (its most prominent, familiar and international form) were Johnnies-come-lately to the Postmodernist French novel, French philosophy, French cinema and the more international manifestations of Postmodernism in the music of Beria, Cage and Schnittke.
My student friend kindly permits me to publish the Barthes-Derrida-Foucault document, all of whose names it bears as well as signatures of assent from Jean-François Lyotard and Giovanni Papini, as it provides for visitors to the exhibition an unvarnished introduction. For infelicities of translation and clarification of the many neologisms (new words even more obscure in French than English), I alone am responsible. The document is headed Manifeste and is as follows:
1. The art of the past is past. What was true of art yesterday is false today.
2. The Postmodern art of today is defined and determined, not by artists, but by a new generation of curators, philosophers and intellectuals ignorant of the past and able to ignore it.
3. Postmodernism is a political undertaking, Marxist and Freudian.
4. Postmodernism is a new cultural condition.
5. Postmodernism is democratic and allied to popular culture.
6. Postmodernism denies the possibility of High Art.
7. Postmodernism deconstructs works of High Art to undermine them.
8. Postmodernism is subversive, seditiously resembling the precedents it mimics.
9. Postmodern art is pastiche, parody, irony, ironic conflict and paradox.
10. Postmodern art is self-consciously shallow, stylistically hybrid, ambiguous, provocative and endlessly repeatable.
11. Postmodern art is anti-elitist, but must protect its own elitism.
12. To the Postmodernist every work of art is a text, even if it employs no words and has no title, to be
curatorially interpreted. Art cannot exist before it is interpreted.
13. Postmodernist interpretation depends on coining new words unknown and unknowable to the masses, on developing a critical jargon of impenetrable profundity, and on a quagmire of theory with which to reinforce endowed significance. Vive le Néologisme!
Thursday, 1 March 2012
Lyotard - The Death of the Metanarrative or The Death of Modernism
Lyotard wrote of the 'death of the metanarratives' or the death of the Enlightenment project' (now often called 'modernity').
Very broadly, this refers to movements in political thought and other ideas from the eighteenth century onwards which proclaimed the
importance of reason, and the knowability of the world through it.
The next step was to argue that, if the world could be known, it could be changed – even for the better… Postmodernism, however, describes these ‘grand narratives’ - Marxism, feminism, belief in scientific progress etc - as nothing more than stories about history, naively structured with happy endings.
Instead postmodernism offers micro-narratives which do not necessarily add up, but which may be woven together, in a jumble of forms and styles.
Very broadly, this refers to movements in political thought and other ideas from the eighteenth century onwards which proclaimed the
importance of reason, and the knowability of the world through it.
The next step was to argue that, if the world could be known, it could be changed – even for the better… Postmodernism, however, describes these ‘grand narratives’ - Marxism, feminism, belief in scientific progress etc - as nothing more than stories about history, naively structured with happy endings.
Instead postmodernism offers micro-narratives which do not necessarily add up, but which may be woven together, in a jumble of forms and styles.
Monday, 23 January 2012
Post Modernism & Mighty Boosh
How Is 'The Mighty Boosh' Postmodern?

The Mighty Boosh is a British comedy written by and starringcomedians Julian Barratt andNoel Fielding. It developed from stage shows to radio shows to a TV show. It focuses mainly on surrealism, fashion and complete and utter fantasy in ways that make it into a completely unique show. Fielding and Barratt's influences include Mr Benn, Monty Python and even Frank Zappa, (an avante guarde musician who released over 60 albums!!!) The show is based around 6 reoccurring characters in Vince Noir, Howard Moon, Bob Fossil, Naboo and Bollo.
The main structure of The Mighty Boosh is that Howard and Vince find some reason to go on some form of adventure, get in trouble and need Naboo to help them out. On these adventures they meet charcters that are used mostly in just one show such as Old Gregg and The Crack Fox.
The show is postmodern in many many ways; it is completely based around fashion and the celebrity culture. Vince and Howard are always trying to find some way of becoming famous, be it through being a photographer, a singer or a poet. Vince's whole character is very much postmodern, even in the clothes he wears.
If you use one of Strinati's features of a postmodern text, confusions over time and space, (which is even a line in the theme tune) this proves it to be a postmodern text because Noel and Julian play exaggerated versions of themselves, perhaps alter egos, similar to Ricky Gervais in Extras. The two comedians actually say this on one of the DVD's extras. This is heightened even more in series 3, episode 3, The Power Of The Crimp, when two people steal Vince and Howard's image. The copiers call themselves Lance Dior and Harrold Boom. This means that there are two people copying two people who are playing exaggerated versions of themselves. There are also many times in the text that create confusion over time and space such as using the Euro even though the show is set in England. Another example is when Gary Numan plays himself in a cameo role but is a different version of himself who lives in a wardrobe in the third series in the shop Vince and Howard work in. Simon Farnaby also plays and actor in the first series called Simon McFarnaby.
The show is based completely on popular culture, however there are times that high art is used and regenerated as pop culture. An example of this is in series 3 when Howard becomes a classical Shakespearian actor but is used in an advert where he plays Sammy The Crab (an actual character in the show, postmodern!) Howard is very much a character based around high art and Vince around pop culture. As the show goes on, the distinction between the two cultures is unravelled.
During the first series there are many times where Vince or Howard directly address the audience in reference to the show. This is self reflexivity. Only in the first series, the two introduce the show and discuss things that will happen in the show. At other times, the two will comment or pull a facial expression to the audience, this is postmodernism similar to in Twenty Four Hour Party People, Nigel Winterbottom 2004.
An emphasis of style over substance, (one of Strinati's features) is that the show is created in a studio. The sets are fake and very much so. There is one point in the first series where they were filming and a piece of the set (a tree) actually fell over when Bryan Ferry (played by Julian, this was not actually Bryan Ferry, it was a jungle man with face paints who drives a motorbike in the jungle, postmodern!!) touches the tree which was not meant to happen but was used for comedic effect.
It uses another of Strinati's features, the breakdown in distinctions between culture and society, when Vince mentions shopping in Camden town and when he makes a device in the third series to track down celebrities. He makes €3000 in one evening because everyone wants to know where these celebrities are, the reflects todays culture.
Music videos are very much a postmodern form of text. To add to the postmodernism this show already has, Barratt and Fielding even include them at points in the show. As Vince changes to a different subcultural group each episode be it mod, goth, electro pop or even a George Clinton style Funk lover, the writers manage to create a small song performed by the characters in a style of music video. The characters act as performers to the audience and many conventions of music videos are used.
Friday, 9 December 2011
An argument against Lyotard's postmodernist argument on Grand Narratives
The collapse of the "Grand Narrative"
One of the old, modernist grand narrative was, and for some still is, that science will solve nearly all our problems. Of course, apart from religious narratives, there are a number of other "grand narratives", too. Hollwood draw on most of the'grand' narratives listed below. One major flaw in Lyotard's argument is that postmodernism, itself, offers its own "grand narrative".

Most famously, in La Condition postmoderne: Rapport sur le savoir (The Postmodern Condition: A Report on Knowledge) (1979), he proposes what he calls an extreme simplification of the "postmodern" as an 'incredulity towards meta-narratives'. These meta-narratives - sometimes 'grand narratives' - are grand, large-scale theories and philosophies of the world, such as the progress of history, the knowability of everything by science, and the possibility of absolute freedom. Lyotard argues that we have ceased to believe that narratives of this kind are adequate to represent and contain us all. We have become alert to difference, diversity, the incompatibility of our aspirations, beliefs and desires, and for that reason postmodernity is characterised by an abundance of micronarratives. From Wikipedia
One of the old, modernist grand narrative was, and for some still is, that science will solve nearly all our problems. Of course, apart from religious narratives, there are a number of other "grand narratives", too. Hollwood draw on most of the'grand' narratives listed below. One major flaw in Lyotard's argument is that postmodernism, itself, offers its own "grand narrative".
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)