Showing posts with label Article. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Article. Show all posts

Wednesday, 2 May 2012

PoMo Blurs Binary opposites: Real/Unreal, Audience/Text, Fixed Identity/Fluid Identity, Man/Machine?


The distrust towards the revolutionary projects of modernity may help explain postmodernism's more relaxed attitude towards the media as a whole. While the media was generally dismissed by modernism as standardized, formulaic and shallow, postmodernism tends to celebrate popular culture generally for its implicit refusal to look for deep universal truths, tending instead to embrace image, surface and ‘depthlessness'.

 This may help explain why postmodern aesthetics appear to indulge in increased levels of intertextuality, generic hybridity, self-reflexivity, pastiche, parody, recycling and sampling. Such characteristics may be seen as reflecting a world where traditional binary oppositions such as ‘fact' and ‘fiction', the ‘real' and the ‘unreal', the ‘authentic' and the ‘inauthentic' are less clear than they may have once seemed.

Indeed, some postmodern critics argue that it is now increasingly impossible to distinguish between the media ‘image' and the ‘real' - each ‘pair has become so deeply intertwined that is difficult to draw the line between the two of them'. In a contemporary society the simulated copy has now even superseded the original object. This phenomenon Baudrillard refers to as the ‘third order of simulacra' which produces a state of ‘hyperreality'.
It is not that simply the line between the media image and the real have become blurred; it is more that the media image and the real are now part of the same entity and are therefore now unable to be separated at all. Some critics have even suggested that the differences between human and machine is now beginning to disappear, tending to eradicate the old ‘human' versus ‘technology' binary opposition upon which so much of the pessimistic theories of modernism were based.

Although the idea of the cyborg (a hybrid of machine and organism) may still be in its scientific infancy, feminist critics already use it as a metaphor for the power to deconstruct essentialist notions of gender and identity in a ‘posthuman' world. For some critics, then, such a theoretical framework gives us a new critical arena through which we can start to understand and account for various aspects of New Media. For example, the postructuralist and postmodernist distrust of a stable and fixed notion of the ‘real' tends to reflect the landscape of New Media where such traditional definitions are increasingly becoming problematized by new technologies.

With the arrival of artificial intelligence, cyberculture, virtual communities and virtual reality, our sense of what is ‘real' and what is ‘unreal' is clearly undergoing a dramatic transformation. 
[Facebook 'friends' - Rich]

For example, real existing companies now place advertisements in virtual worlds like Second Life, an artificial environment which affects real existing sales.
So how can we separate the ‘real' in this example from the ‘virtual'? What part of this virtual world is ‘real' and what part of it is not? Admittedly, this is an extreme example, but it is an illustration of the wider kinds of technological and cultural change that developments in New Media are currently producing. As this suggests, this problematizing of what we once recognized as ‘real' will inevitably influence the very notion we may have of an ‘authentic self', the conception of identity in a postmodern world becoming increasingly fluid and contestable. In particular, it has been argued that the increased interactivity of New Media generally allows audiences to play around with and make their own composite identities from various and sometimes even contradictory sources. This process is referred to by some as ‘DIY citizenship', the notion that the media now allows us to all create our own complex, diverse and many faceted notions of personal identity.

With so many different communities now open to us on the web, we can begin to simply pick and choose which identities we want to adopt and which ones we want to reject, allowing an individual to decide how they define themselves rather than simply having to stick to the narrow and limited number of choices that once defined the past. This is in stark contrast to a world where identity is primarily a matter of heritage.

This fluid notion of identity certainly appears to be in direct contrast to the concept of citizenship and identity that was propagated by the underpinnings that informed the roots of modernism, particularly a concept like public service broadcasting. Postmodernist critics might argue that even the notion of ‘broadcasting' itself is a totalizing concept which was never able to successfully reflect the sheer diversity of a nation or its people.
The phrase ‘narrowcasting' - that is used to denote New Media's pronounced interest in addressing and catering for niche audiences - perhaps better encapsulates the role of television and radio in a world of multimedia. As we have seen, the increased interactivity of audiences in a New Media context is also articulated in poststructuralist theory whose tendency is to conceive the audience as active participators in the creation of meaning.

Websites like YouTube, MySpace and Facebook appear to reflect this recent understanding of ‘participatory culture'; not only creating virtual communities but also allowing audiences to become ‘producers' as well as ‘receivers' of the media. Theories of ‘fandom' are important here with the Internet allowing the fans of different forms of culture to create virtual communities that add to the original understanding and even content of their chosen interests. For example, the rise of ‘slash fiction' allows audiences to actively participate in the production of meaning by creating extratextual material about their favourite television programmes.
Consequently, rather than being seen as essentially commercial and inactive, in a postmodern world consumption itself is now regarded as a positive and participatory act. Indeed, the ‘top-down' cultural ‘uplift' seems particularly redundant in a world where audiences are increasingly determining their own choice of media and what they do with it. The hypertextual ‘cut' and ‘paste' culture of New Media - that seemingly encourages sampling, poaching and remixing - produces not only copyright problems, it also further confuses the very means by which we conceive of the media and its relationship with its audience. [Remember last year Music Industry?] 

Certainly, the idea that a media organization like the BBC could so rigidly dictate public tastes seems almost unimaginable now. We may now require a completely new theory of authorship to help us understand the current relationship between the media and its audience.

Wednesday, 25 April 2012

XFactor Case Study: How is the audience/text relationship changing?

Artifice is the name of The X Factor game

15 December 2011
The real deal?

The gigantic, apocalyptic glittering ball of The X Factor reflects back only what we give it, argues Will Brooker




Credit: Rex Features
Little Mix: 'an escalation of the true, of the lived experience...a panic-stricken production of the real'

In 1988, Fredric Jameson wrote - half in mourning, half in warning - of a contemporary "world in which stylistic innovation is no longer possible...all that is left is to imitate dead styles, to speak through the masks and with the voices of the styles in the imaginary museum". If 1980s postmodernism was a hall of mirrors, recycling and reflecting the past, Wembley Arena on the night of The X Factor final is a fractured mosaic, a spinning mirrorball of snatched images thrown up on the big screen. The irony is as thick as the fog thrown up by the dry ice. Dermot O'Leary urges the crowd to vote for the winner, although the guest appearances are from JLS (runners-up, 2008) in a mash-up with One Direction (runners-up, 2010), hosted by Olly Murs (runner-up in 2009). Every loser wins, it seems, and yet the audience is told repeatedly that fame rests on this final performance.

"When the real is no longer what it used to be," Jean Baudrillard proposed, "nostalgia assumes its full meaning'.

That 1980s trend of recycling and dressing up, of desperate searching for scraps in the cultural wreckage; that breathless, blink-and-you'll-miss-it aesthetic of multiple masks, voices and styles, reaches hysterical levels in Saturday's show. Little Mix, the first band to reach the final, is in essence a tribute act to Girls Aloud, the winners of another pop music reality show nine years ago; each of their songs is drilled with military precision, complete with glitter cannon, snappy salutes and airborne leaps on to the stage. Despite the slick spectacle and the rehearsed soundbites, their mentor, Tulisa, insists constantly that her "little muffins" are genuine and authentic; as evidence, they're shown crying, hugging their mums and talking about bullying. One of them, Jesy, worries about her weight, which is translated as having "real" curves and being a "real" girl.

Their rival is Marcus Collins, the first out gay man to reach the final; he performed on a real plane surrounded by short-skirted dolly birds in a pastiche of television's Pan Am, itself a pale copy of Mad Men, itself a nostalgia trip back to a 1960s that never was. The "mode rétro" discussed in Jameson's article - films in the style of an earlier time - now seems quaintly simple and straightforward, compared with this mise en abyme of frames within frames. There is no "original" at the heart of this performance, any more than Girls Aloud are "authentic" artists inspiring a copy in Little Mix. Open up one postmodern parcel, and there's always another inside. Derrida - Deconstruction (everything can be linked to a reference to something else)

"If I was looking for a perfect pop star and fed everything into a computer...I'd get Marcus Collins!" shrilled Louis Walsh, meaning it as a compliment. (Irony?) In the audience, a boy held up a simulation of Marcus' face, sculpted from toast and Marmite. "When he's onstage, everybody just wants to look at him," Gary Barlow announced proudly; but the camera lingered longer on the toast-and-Marmite replica of the singer than on Marcus himself.

In Wembley Arena, where the show is broadcast live, nobody was actually looking at Marcus, either; they were looking at the big screen, or at the tiny windows on their own phones. There were 10,000 people in a hangar together watching a giant television, and half of them were filming the television to watch later (fascinated by/preferring the simulation). Marcus himself, grinning bravely onstage, had become almost irrelevant; he looked like a little man who's wandered out of a huge screen. "Something has changed," as Baudrillard mused. "With the television image - the television being the ultimate and perfect object for this new era - our own body and the whole surrounding universe become a control screen." The larger-than-life close-up of the singer has become more fascinating than the diminutive, silhouetted figure onstage (heightened simulation); but more important yet is the home-made, hand-held digital video, the grainy, shaky video ready to be uploaded to Facebook as an authentic souvenir, the proof that they were actually there (Hyper-real). If it can't be tweeted or uploaded, it could be argued that it didn't happen at all.(the death of the real)

The members of the audience know that they are also part of a structured reality show, and they embrace the artifice. They're told to boo when the judges say something they don't like, and to cheer when they approve, but they already know the routine. This is a church of the devoted, a place of happy ritual. They cheer the playback of the songs performed an hour ago because they look much more exciting on video, with the camera swooping and swirling around static performers. They cheer last night's show, already colour-coded in washed-out blue as "history". They cheer the bursts of flame, because the heat feels authentic and reminds them that this is "live". They cheer the Coldplay wristbands when they light up, transforming them into part of the show. They cheer the confetti falling from the ceiling: a wedding between audience and the TV, between simulation and the real.

Dermot O'Leary asks the contestants and their families how they feel, digging for an emotional response. Tears come, on cue. But hidden beneath a camera is another, far smaller and more subtle screen: black, with white text. "HOW DOES IT FEEL, AND WHAT WOULD YOU WANT TO SAY?" Dermot's words appear on screen before he recites them. "THEY EXIT," the screen commands, like a Shakespeare stage direction. Dermot and Marcus exit obediently. Enter Little Mix. The screen scrolls upwards. "JADE: THERE'S STILL A LITTLE BIT OF YOUR TASTE IN MY MOUTH." Onstage, Jade reads the words, and dutifully sings the first line of Cannonball, the winner's song. THIS IS THE REFERRING TO AUTOCUE (RICH)

So it really is karaoke; the lines are scripted, the lyrics are provided. But does it matter? The people in the audience aren't stupid: it's not that they believe it's improvised, it's that they don't care. The difference between simulation and the real doesn't matter any more. The two are mashed-up, mixed-up, merged. It's the 2011 show, the ultimate end-of-the-pier show, the penultimate end-of-the-year show, the all-singing, all-dancing post-apocalypso, the panto at the end of the universe. And it's our show, whether we like it or not, because Wembley Arena is not a bubble of spectacle and showmanship, isolated from the rest of society. The gigantic, apocalyptic, glittering ball of The X Factor reflects back only what we give it:

Outside is the world of fake bloggers, rigged political votes, structured reality, YouTube pop stars, holograms in pantomime and protesters in comic-book masks; albums from dead singers, scripted political debates, simulated flash mobs, arrests for Facebook pages, Twitter rumours, online bomb threats and TV marriages shorter than an advert break. As Baudrillard said of Disneyland, the arena's artifice exists to convince us that the world outside is real. In fact, that world looks an awful lot like The X Factor.

"Illusion is no longer possible," Baudrillard asserts, "because the real is no longer possible." Nevertheless, as Jade reads the words from the screen, she breaks rank and pronounces one lyric in her own speaking voice, and Perrie, her band partner, echoes it in a South Shields accent. "What's goin' on?" these two girls ask each other, onstage in front of 10,000 people. "We're seeing four little pop princesses being born," Louis exults, like a proud father. "How do you feel?" asks Dermot again.

Is this a last glimpse of the "real", as four young women exchange incredulous glances and can't believe what's going on, as they make the transition from authenticity into celebrity? The glitter cannon fires, demanding an encore. It's time for Little Mix to face the crowd, to read the autocue, to embrace the autotune, to face the music.

Post-Modern Futures: A different kind of reality TV

A different kind of reality TV
The Only Way is Essex has won a Bafta and Made in Chelsea is the talk of Twitter. So is this strange blend of fact and drama the future of entertainment TV?

Julia Raeside
The Guardian, Wednesday 1 June 2011

The cast of The Only Way is Essex celebrate winning a Bafta award in May 2011.





The inexorable rise of constructed reality television was boosted last week when ITV2's The Only Way is Essex took home Bafta's YouTube Audience Award, beating the likes of Downton Abbey, Miranda and Sherlock to the prize. As the canny director at the ceremony cut to a close-up of Martin Freeman, the actor's expression spoke volumes about the television establishment's reaction to a bunch of spray-tanned amateurs waltzing off with a trophy more usually afforded to skilled craftspeople. (judgements of taste over populism) He wasn't angry with the voting public, just disappointed.

In an age when TV fakery scandals have caused public uproar, why is a huge audience buying into something so obviously artificial? Most television involves a level of artifice. Everything from The Apprentice to Top Gear uses sleight of hand to better convey the story of each episode. But this new hybrid genre – of which E4's Made in Chelsea is another example – is neither fiction nor reality but a strange marriage of the two. Are we supposed to believe it?

The Only Way is Essex arrived soon after the end of Channel 4's Big Brother last year and is a crossbreed of soap and documentary. It features a cast of real people, living around Brentwood, Buckhurst Hill and Chigwell, going about their daily lives. They are brash, fake-tanned and young. And, most importantly, they conform to the stereotypes of Essex man and woman. He is flash, arrogant and sexually prolific. She is obsessed with beauty treatments and snaring the aforementioned Jack-the-lad.

Programme makers Lime Pictures advertised in various Essex publications, on Facebook and via word-of-mouth to assemble their key players. Mark Wright and Lauren Goodger have been together for nine years and spent most of the first series splitting up and reuniting. Amy Childs, beautician and glamour girl, and a group of friends had already made attempts to break into television, auditioning for Big Brother, The X Factor and various other reality shows.

"They had a pre-existing relationship and they wanted [to do] something like this. So when we met one of them – it was Amy first, actually – all of the others were queuing up behind. This was not a particularly difficult group of people to find," says Tony Wood, creative director of Lime Pictures.

What you see on screen looks like drama but it is, the producers claim, based on the real lives of their subjects. "Story producers" plot out what they are going to film in advance after discussion with the cast – they prime their subjects to discuss certain topics, with an outcome in mind, although they cannot always predict that outcome.

Daran Little, who acted as story producer on the first series of The Only Way is Essex and E4's Made in Chelsea, which is about rich young adults in west London, says it's a delicate process that requires careful handling. "If there's a boy and a girl in a scene, you'll pull them over individually and you'll say: 'Right, in this scene I want you to ask her what she did last night.' Because I know what she did last night, but he doesn't. Then we start the scene and they just talk it through and if it gets a bit dry, we'll stop and pull them to one side and we'll say: 'How do you feel about him asking you that? Because I think you feel more emotional about it. I think you're pulling something back. Do you think it's fair that he's asking you this?'"

The Only Way is Essex was not the first structured reality show to hit British screens but it's certainly had the biggest impact – it has attracted a peak audience of 1.5 million. Interestingly, many of the production team have backgrounds in drama and not factual television. Lime Pictures also makes the long-running teen soap Hollyoaks, and Wood previously spent two years as the show runner on Coronation Street.

Lime began the UK trend for these documentary/drama hybrids back in 2006 when MTV asked it to make a British version of the hit US show Laguna Beach: The Real Orange County, altering it to be about a group of rich teenagers in Alderley Edge, Cheshire. The US show was inspired by teen drama The OC and borrowed many of its techniques to create a kind of real-life soap. "Living on the Edge was essentially a reality show that was repackaged a little bit to make it look glossy and look like drama," says Wood. "There were very few contrivances within it but you had the latitude to be able to put an emotional mix on it, in a sense."

Living on the Edge ran for two series and, although not a ratings hit, set a pattern for programmes that followed. British TV executives couldn't fail to notice the huge US success of programmes such as The Hills and The City (spin-off shows from Laguna Beach); staged documentaries that followed beautiful, wealthy teenagers as they went about their privileged lives. They were aspirational, escapist and focused almost exclusively on the romantic attachments of the cast.

Little, who has previously written for EastEnders, Coronation Street and the US soap All My Children, says that during his time in America, the schedules were overrun with similar reality dramas. "There are so many reality TV shows in the States and if you're going to avoid them, then you might as well avoid television," he says. And now they are springing up all over our digital schedules amid press accusations that scenes are being "faked" and relationships are being "manufactured" to assist the narrative.

Little insists the production process is very much at the mercy of the participants and not the other way around. "I get to know them," he says. "They tell me what's going on in their own lives. They tell me things they want to do, or hope to do. I structure, scene by scene, what should happen in each episode to draw out the drama and the comedy. Then we schedule the scenes."

A drama is only as good as its actors and, at first glance, these shows appear to be almost entirely peopled by artless hams – yet they're hugely popular with their target audiences. When Little interviewed Made in Chelsea cast members Ollie Locke and Gabriella Ellis, he instantly spotted their potential. "They had been together for a year. I talked to them together and their body language was completely different to what they were saying. And I thought, this is a relationship which is crumbling and she's not too aware of it. And he's hurting her. Oh my goodness, this will actually make very good television."

And, sure enough, in episode three, Ollie dumped Gabriella on the deck of a Thames pleasure cruiser, surrounded by fairy lights. Little says Ollie had called the production team and told them he needed to end the relationship so they swung into action to set up a suitable shot. While Ollie gave it his all in the scene, Gabriella looked genuinely upset. The next episode, he came out as bisexual. Faked content is one thing, but the idea that it's all real is perhaps even more disturbing.

The shows have the glossy production values of a soap but are performed by people who don't have the skill to convincingly communicate emotion in full makeup, under bright lights, while hitting their marks. Wood says filming scenes more than once isn't always an option with real people. "We very, very rarely go to multiple takes. I spend a lot of time in the edit and if in the cutting room you're presented with a take where they're clearly manufacturing their emotions, it's tough to make a decent scene out of that."

But it's clear that this is often the only option. It's the lack of emotional truth that has so confused and repelled some viewers. Wood claims that the confusion is exactly what the makers were aiming for when they made their chronicle of the Essex community.

"At the heart of this was always a desire to put in the audience's mind: 'Is it real? Are they acting? Is it scripted? Is it not?' and to leave that as an open question for them," he says.

What he describes almost sounds like Brecht's Verfremdungseffekt or "alienation effect". (Brecht described this as "stripping an event of its self-evident, familiar, obvious quality and creating a sense of astonishment and curiosity about [it]".) Wood laughs off the comparison but agrees their techniques aren't dissimilar. The usual soap tricks – music, editing, a narrative arc – encourage the viewer to engage, while they are simultaneously held at arm's length by the cast's apparent lack of emotional integrity.

But to what end? To generate debate on social networking sites, drive curious viewers to the TV product and keep the advertisers happy? It's as if what's actually in the shows has ceased to matter.

"The content seems to be a Marmite issue for people: you love it or you hate it," says Fergus O'Brien, the documentary-maker responsible for BBC2's The Armstrongs, a fly-on-the-wall documentary that itself had audiences questioning whether the hilarious titular couple could really be the genuine article. (They were.) "Some people think it's deceiving people to suggest there is anything real about it; others say it's harmless fun," he says.

O'Brien directed Channel 4's Seven Days earlier this year. The series chronicled the lives of residents of London's Notting Hill over a week and, although it didn't use staged scenes, gave the audience a chance to interact with the cast during filming. It proved less successful than The Only Way is Essex in terms of ratings, but it attempted to do something new with the documentary form at a time when every production company in the land was trying to predict what would come along to fill the yawning chasm left by Big Brother.

"It covered the real events and interactions of the characters over a seven-day period and embraced the feedback loop that naturally generated around the characters as the week went by," O'Brien explains. The participants would see their stories play out on the screen while filming continued thanks to a fast turn-around production schedule. Whereas Made in Chelsea was already finished when it started transmission, the Essex cast are able to see themselves on television as each episode is shot, edited and broadcast within a three-day period.

Wood traces his fascination with the genre back to the moment when, in 2007, Jade Goody emerged from the Celebrity Big Brother house and into the media hurricane of the Shilpa Shetty race row. It was that moment of simultaneous celebrity and sudden self-knowledge that he hoped to expand on in The Only Way is Essex.

"What I wanted to do was set up a situation in which people are living in the full glare of the beam of that fame. And they're realising what the public are saying about them and it's completely open and they're potentially on quite a difficult ride as a result of that," he says.

"We deliberately showed, at the top of episode two, the cast watching the episode that had just gone out. So we gave the message that this is what the game is," he adds. When Lime pitched the show to ITV originally, it described it as "Big Brother without the walls".

But during a decade of Big Brother, despite the presence of storyline producers and careful editing, the reality created inside a bungalow in Borehamwood felt somehow more honest than the shaped and refined sagas currently coming out of Essex and Chelsea, which have hints of real emotion but nothing to touch the visceral highs and lows of Big Brother at its best. These new shows remain in the digital hinterland for now but are having a significant impact thanks to Twitter and the tabloids' interest in the cast. As the Bafta-night reaction highlighted, The Only Way is Essex has replaced Big Brother as the programme people sneer about at dinner parties without having seen it. But is it any worse, in terms of artifice, than character-driven factual shows such as The Apprentice or MasterChef?

Little says hindsight will invest this apparently superficial genre with cultural importance, just as it did with the Carry On films. "Retrospectively, these wonderful programmes are being made about what a genius Kenneth Williams was and how tortured Hattie Jacques was and the great art of the Carry On film. Well, give it 10, 15 years and people will be writing theses on The Only Way is Essex."

Thursday, 19 April 2012

Baudrillard & Hyper-reality

Link

Are the Gorillaz Post-Modern?


A cartoon? A cult band? A political collective? Damon Albarn having a laugh? What exactly is/are The Gorillaz – and what can they teach us about popular culture and post-modernism?
Four cartoon characters, two puppets, one big screen, two choirs, dancers, backing singers, stars including De la Soul, Roots Manuva and Shaun Ryder, and most importantly a group of musicians in the mysterious anonymity of shadows, recently played a string of one-off gigs which reportedly will never be repeated.
The Gorillaz’ live performance of their Demon Days album lasted five nights at the Manchester Opera House. Tickets sold out in just over an hour, leading to blackmarket sales of up to £150 a ticket.
But whilst the names of lead singer/keyboardist 2D, bassist Murdoc, lead guitarist Noodle and drummer Russel are familiar to music fans, Dan Nakamura (replaced by DJ Dangermouse for the Demon Days album), Miho Hatori, Tina Weymouth and Jamie Hewlett are not as well known. Not so co-creator Damon Albarn, whose popularity in 90s’ Britpop band Blur doubtlessly contributed to The Gorillaz’ slogan ‘Reject False Icons’.
So how can The Gorillaz help us to understand the concept of postmodernism? Postmodernism is at once both an aesthetic style, something we can recognise in media texts, and also a state of cultural being, the way we are. Culturally, postmodernism is a three-pronged fork:
  • sociologically it describes the way society is increasingly characterised by consumerism, information technology, and globalisation
  • psychologically it describes audiences’ increasing ability to navigate and communicate in the technologically driven modern world, but also the resulting changes to our sense of identity
  • philosophically, it suggests that ‘absolute truths’ are non-existent, and questions the concept of ‘reality’.

A high concept band?

Gorillaz is a high-concept collective of artists and musicians...
(MTV)...the band’s high concept shenanigans... (NME)
True pop art, as high-concept as a Warhol soup can, but it works (The Rolling Stone)
So what is ‘high concept’? High concept doesn’t refer to the band at all, but rather the marketing of the band. In simple terms, The Gorillaz are a collection of musicians, making music in a generically eclectic style, almost anonymously. But anonymity doesn’t sell. Not even in a media market where music snobs reject ‘manufactured’ pop and pseudo-individualised music is the music alone ‘enough’.
What to do? Bring in Jamie Hewlett, animator of (amongst others) the cult Tank Girl franchise, to create cartoon characters 2D, Murdoc, Noodle and Russel. This solves the immediate problem, because now music bosses have something to put on the CD covers, posters, T-shirts and in music videos, which is all very useful because they like to make money. But what about all those audiophiles who want to see live music? Not to worry; stick up a big sheet to hide the musicians, and project the characters on to it. That’s the ticket. Literally. Between 2001 and 2005 that’s exactly how The Gorillaz performed in sell-out shows, as ‘virtual personalities’ serving audiences with pop music from outside the shackles of the cult of celebrity. In theory, this separates the music from the far more saleable star persona but, in reality, audiences became fans of fictional characters; the ‘high concept’ shifted their interest into the profitable realm of cult fandom.


Experimental – or an economic investment?
But
are The Gorillaz really all that experimental or innovative? Is it really a risk to create animated characters when animations are some of the highest grossing films of all time? Even for The Gorillaz’ target audience, whose edgy sensibility might reject the Pixar/Disney formula, Tarantino’s recent Kill Bill regenerated interest in the Japanese animĂ© that informs Hewlett’s creations. The band’s acceptance speech at the 2005 European MTV Awards showcased some of the holographic technology that the band have promised for a 2007 tour.
Offering audiences the spectacle of pioneering technology in the information age (Postmodernity?) is hardly an economic risk. And just as Albarn brought to The Gorillaz a fan base that has, as he has himself, matured from Britpop, Hewlett brought his own fanbase, from 90s’ cult comic strip and film, Tank Girl, and if there’s one thing cult fans are willing to do to illustrate their fandom, it’s spend money. Far from being original, The Gorillaz simply cut up the pieces of established styles and genres, to create something new, a technique known in postmodernism as ‘bricolage’.

NME’s Peter Robinson illustrated the band’s boardroom appeal in a review of The Gorillaz earlier this year
If you were to invent a pop act right now, where would you begin? Well, human beings take too many drugs and start boo-hooing when they don’t get their own way, so you’d create something, like a cartoon character, to front the whole shebang. You’d do something to make sure The Kids’ parents didn’t understand the appeal – it’s the punk rock way, after all. And since we live in such modern times, you’d promote this new pop star not through conventional channels like the gig circuit or CD:UK, but through some semi-interactive platform, to star with the world’s most-can’t-get-out-of-your-headable tune, and once the entire project reached critical mass, whack out a single. Congratulations: you’ve just invented the Crazy Frog.


He certainly has a point; but surely the Crazy Frog’s not quite as political as Hewlett and Albarn’s alter egos. Tracks on their recent album include the social commentaries ‘Kids With Guns’ and the obscurely named ‘Fire Coming Out of a Monkey’s Head’. The music video for ‘19-2000’ features the characters being bombed and bombing, and ‘Dirty Harry’ features 2D in a soldier’s uniform, complete with helmet and dogtags, dancing to entertain a group of children. Perhaps most bizarrely for a band which is supposed to be about the music rather than the image, Albarn began a 2001 acceptance speech for Best Dance Act with:

"F*** the music,’ going on to say, ‘See this symbol? It’s the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament. Bombing one of the poorest countries in the world is wrong. You’ve got the voice, use it."
A focus on the fundamentals of the music was a characteristic of modernist music, and The Gorillaz are about a decade too late for that bandwagon. In postmodern music, the cultural image surrounding the music, which reverberates through film, television, and other media, is all that matters. With star personae, technically innovative graphic arts and a pseudo-political voice, it looks like The Gorillaz have got all bases covered.


Reject False Icons
Having
fronted Blur in the 90s, Albarn knows better than most about the superficiality of fandom. Screaming audiences have become commonplace since Beatlemania in the 60s, and this has accelerated, leading to groups created in music bosses’ boardrooms along the principles of ‘image now, music later’. The Gorillaz’ slogan, Reject False Icons, appears to confront this trend; challenging the audience to care about the music, rather than the performer. This is quite a feat for former fans of Blur, or fans of any other musicians who represent themselves, as the audience’s pleasure in identifying with musical icons – the essence of conventional fandom – is swept away. For generations Marxists have critiqued the way Capitalism commodifies popular culture, packaging desirable social identities in purchasable pop acts; Albarn’s role in The Gorillaz reinforces their argument: he is lead vocalist, but not front man, identities which are usually one and the same.




The Gorillaz’ virtual identities – including a 10-year-old Japanese guitar prodigy (Noodle) and a Satan-loving ex-convict (Murdoc) – appeals to audiences’ interest in the fluidity and diversity of identity popularised by Freud, in a playful, pleasurable way. This problematising of identity and reality, along with the band’s eclectic mix of hip-hop, punk and dub reggae genres, are prime characteristics of postmodernism, according to influential thinker Jean Francois Lyotard.
The ‘anything goes’ sensibility of postmodernism is certainly recognisable in The Gorillaz. Live artists perform alongside the animations; many contributors are simply ‘moonlighting’ in The Gorillaz alongside their roles in other bands (Shaun Ryder), solo acts (Neneh Cherry), films (Dennis Hopper) or equally anonymous masked acts (MF Doom). Whilst a fictional animated band might seem a shrewd move in an industry where bands are notorious for fall outs, diva demands and drink or drug problems, The Gorillaz website gives a full run down of the band members’ trials and tribulations. Murdoc, for example, has been in prison for ripping off a Mexican whorehouse, Noodle is one of 23 children trained as part of an elite military team, and good natured front man 2D is constantly battling bullying from Murdoc.


So if ‘anything goes’ in the postmodern world, who’s to say what’s good and what’s bad? Money. Here is where the postmodernists and Marxists differ. For the postmodernists, in the absence of any aesthetic criteria, profit becomes the criteria of worth. For the Marxists, such mass appeal is exactly the opposite, a marker of cultural triviality.

Performance
In
their music videos, The Gorillaz always appear as fully animated characters, conforming to all the conventions of the medium, including scenes where they are playing instruments and others where they are acting out a story. The artists collaborating with The Gorillaz, however, are often ‘disembodied’ in the music videos; De la Soul appear on screens in ‘Feel Good Inc.’, and Shaun Ryder appears as a decapitated head in ‘Dare’. Such representations serve playfully to question the concept of realism, as the cartoons become more fully rounded characters than those depicted using photographic realism.
This
technique was reversed in the band’s recent live performances, where the musicians remained in shadows and the collaborating artists took to the spotlight at the front of the stage. Until November 2005, the musicians always played from behind the curtain, enigmatic enough to generate cult interest and providing music fans a unique selling point to demarcate The Gorillaz in a genre-flooded market.

For five nights in November, The Gorillaz revealed themselves, in a series of highly publicised gigs at the Manchester Opera House. This event, trailing the Manchester International Festival of film, theatre, visual arts and science in 2007, challenged further the nature of what The Gorillaz actually is. Until now, they have been an anonymous band, playing popular music from behind the mask of some animated characters. At the Opera House, a setting known for high cultural theatrical performances, The Gorillaz played in person, albeit in shadows, to a packed auditorium, where the audience sat down.
The performance featured the band, two choirs and a set of violinists and cellists; a total of 80 musicians including guest appearances from Shaun Ryder, Ike Turner, De la Soul and Roots Manuva. Rather than a traditional support act at a live gig, a big screen played a comical animation, and two life size puppets of Murdoc and 2D MC’d. The programme was made up of four prints of Hewlett’s artwork and a letter of introduction from the Festival director, Alex Poots. This spectacle of popular music and performance drawn from an eclectic mix of genres and visual arts, in the beautiful architecture of the Opera House, and the context of an international arts festival, blurred the boundaries between what we might understand as high culture and popular culture in the contemporary arts.

Identity
Do
The Gorillaz really exist at all? There are musicians who play, but they remain nameless, and more importantly in the visually-dominated twenty-first century, image-less. There are cartoons projected onto giant screens, but we all know cartoons can’t play music, however accustomed modern audiences are to suspending disbelief to enter fictional narrative worlds. The Gorillaz conduct their own interviews – Albarn claims that the group don’t like it when he speaks for them – and when they win awards, they accept with fully animated acceptance speeches. So surely the band does exist in their own right – how could a fictional band win ‘Best Group’ at the 2005 European MTV awards?
Whilst
the characters can’t be matched to the musicians like-for-like, there are some obvious similarities. Lead singer 2D visually resembles lead vocalist and co-creator Damon Albarn. American hip-hopper turned drummer Russel may represent the original producer of the band Dan Nakamura, and guitarist Noodle may be influenced by Miho Hatori. Visually at least, bassist Murdoc seems to have no real-world referent.
But it may be exactly this ambiguity of identity that appeals to fans of The Gorillaz, as increased cultural fragmentation has led to the consideration of the self as socially constructed and subject to change, rather than ‘fixed’. The Gorillaz’ primary target audience (late teens and twentysomethings) are the demographic group which experience perhaps the greatest changes in cultural identity, in many cases ‘trying on’ different cultural personae, complete with different styles of dress and interests in music.
Such a transformation is evident in Albarn himself; he has metamorphasised from a retro-tracksuited attention-seeking Britpop heartthrob to an unlikely popstar, complete with growing waistline and receding hairline, hiding in the shadows. In The Gorillaz, however, looks don’t matter. And for those listening to their CD, or watching Hewlett’s animations in their latest video, whether The Gorillaz really exist doesn’t really matter either.


So are The Gorillaz Postmodern?
The
Gorillaz are arguably an expression of postmodern culture. Sociologically, they use the media of information and communication technology to critique the marketing practices of the music industry, whilst marketing themselves. How ironic.

Psychologically, they illustrate how audiences enjoy the hybridity of cultural forms and genres, and respond to the fluidity of identity represented, accepting and adapting to the new relationships of fandom between artists and audiences. They blur the boundaries of high and popular culture, once considered fixed, by placing popular music in a high cultural context just as the great surreal artist Marcel Duchamp might place a urinal in an art gallery.
Philosophically, they pose questions around the nature of representation, performance and existence, as they play with modes and expressions of realism.
But as The Gorillaz attempt to transcend classification, perhaps it’s pointless to pigeonhole them into the label of ‘postmodern’. In many ways they are, and in many ways they are not. For the casual listener, they are another band playing catchy tunes with a sometimes pseudo-political voice. But for the real fan, who in being a fan of The Gorillaz has to come to terms with what ‘being a fan’ actually means, The Gorillaz offers much more than just good fun.